September 01, 2004

Researchers Conclude Nidek MK-2000 is Better than Hansatome and ACS Microkeratomes

Comparison of corneal flap thickness between primary and fellow eyes using three microkeratomes

Journal of Refractive Surgery
Volume 20, Issue 5, September 2004, Pages 417-421

Shemesh, G., Leibovitch, I. , Lipshitz, I.
Ophthalmic Health Center
Department of Ophthalmology, Tel-Aviv Sourasky Medical Center, Tel-Aviv


PURPOSE:  To compare corneal flap thickness created in laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) in primary (right) and fellow (left) eyes (same blade for both eyes) using three microkeratomes.

METHODS:  The corneal thickness of 132 eyes (66 patients) was measured preoperatively and intraoperatively after flap creation. Corneal flap thickness was calculated by subtracting stromal bed thickness from total corneal thickness. Three microkeratomes were used: Nidek MK-2000, Bausch and Lomb Surgical Hansatome, and the Chiron Automated Corneal Shaper (ACS). Each patient had both corneas cut by one microkeratome and one blade at the same session

RESULTS:  Mean corneal flap thickness created in primary eyes was 128.30 ▒ 12.57 Ám (range 105 to 147 Ám) for the ACS (160-Ám plate and 8.5-mm ring) and 122.96 ▒ 13.30 Ám (range 86 to 140 Ám) for fellow eyes; Hansatome (160-Ám plate and 8.5-mm ring): 141.16 ▒ 20.11 Ám (range 101 to 169 Ám) in primary eyes and 120.95 ▒ 26.95 Ám (range 107 to 151 Ám) in fellow eyes; Nidek (130-Ám plate and 8.5-mm ring): 127.25 ▒ 4.12 Ám (range 116 to 134 Ám) in primary eyes and 127.54 ▒ 3.7 Ám (range 119 to 134 Ám) in fellow eyes. The corneal flap in the ACS and Hansatome microkeratomes was always thicker in the primary than the fellow eye, using the same blade for both eyes.  No significant difference was found using the Nidek microkeratome.

CONCLUSION: Corneal flap thickness tended to be thinner in fellow eyes than in primary eyes for the ACS and Hanstome microkeratomes.  The Nidek microkeratome results were closer to specified corneal flap thickness than the ACS and Hanstome microkeratomes.

Posted by Admin at September 1, 2004 06:34 PM